Recognising the importance of measurable maturity, NIST references several cryptographic transition models like those addressing post-quantum cryptography. Given NIST’s influence on cybersecurity practice, these models may shape organizational planning and governance mechanisms. However, their design quality has not been systematically evaluated. This work assesses three industry-driven maturity models against established design principles. The analysis reveals recurring weaknesses, specifically a lack of measurable, reproducible assessment criteria and limited prescriptive guidance for improving crypto agility. Simultaneously, this research highlights individual strengths within each model.






